Western Michigan University Athletics

Fantasy Summary

An undrafted late-bloomer with dynamic offensive instincts. His average frame and skating may hold him back at the NHL but he has scored buckets of points at every level so far.


Observations

Click to Expand

October 2024 – McAllister is thriving in an elevated role in Charlotte. Many perceived his 2023-24 campaign as disappointing, but McAllister is proving he can be an elite playmaker at the professional level. McAllister has five assists, leading the Checkers in four games in that category. He is a powerplay threat threading seam passes, leading to his teammates capitalizing. There remain concerns about McAllister’s projectability to the NHL as he is far less productive five-on-five and has a subpar shot. Still, if the playmaking capabilities allow him to make the jump, McAllister could be a bottom-six playmaker on the top powerplay unit. Time will tell with McAllister, but at the moment, he seems to be stuck in prospect purgatory. James Connelly

September 2024 – McAllister had a rough rookie year at the professional level. After scoring five points in his first four AHL games in 2022-23, McAllister took a noticeable step back in 2023-24, producing only 19 points in 37 games. McAllister’s game is built on his passing, but he could not find the passes he used to make in the NCAA. He will likely bounce back in the 2024-25 season and is a strong candidate to play in the Checkers’ top six, where he will look to establish himself among the top call-up options. James Connelly

June 2023 – Florida fans were thrilled this past April to land the high-scoring McAllister, an undrafted free agent who took an unconventional route to an NHL contract: he spent three years in the little-known AJHL, where he dominated in 2021-22 (139 points in 60 games), before taking the NCAA by storm and scoring 49 points in 39 games as a freshman. Given his overage status, his numbers should be taken with a grain of salt, but his stunning college transition establishes him as a legitimate prospect. McAllister makes up for his average skating and shot with a dynamic playmaking and passing game. Despite scoring five points in his first four AHL games, expect growing pains as he learns to navigate professional hockey as an undersized, slower-skating forward. Ben Gehrels

Attributes
Fantasy Upside 5.5
NHL Certainty 5.0
Country CAN
Position C
Roster Type Minors
Shoot/Glove Left
Date of Birth December 19, 2001
Height 5‘10”
Weight 183 lbs
Drafted No

Stats

 Season Team League GP G A TP PIM      Playoffs GP G A TP PIM 
 2015-2016 Elgin Middlesex Canucks U15 AAAALLIANCE U15- - -- -|        
 2016-2017 London Jr. Knights Green U16 AAU16 AA- - -- -|        
 2017-2018 London Jr. Knights U18 AAAALLIANCE U1825 25 2146 11|Playoffs7 3 47
 2018-2019 London NationalsGOJHL31 7 1219 4|        
  Komoka KingsGOJHL16 4 1418 10|Playoffs12 4 48
 2019-2020 Prince George Spruce KingsBCHL37 5 813 14|        
  Brooks BanditsAJHL19 8 917 4|        
 2020-2021 Brooks BanditsAJHL20 5 813 2|        
 2021-2022 Brooks BanditsAJHL60 57 82139 38|Playoffs13 10 1929 20 
  Brooks BanditsCentennial Cup6 8 1018 2|        
 2022-2023 Western Michigan Univ.NCAA39 13 3649 14|        
  Charlotte CheckersAHL4 1 45 0|Playoffs3 1 12
 2023-2024 Charlotte CheckersAHL37 8 1119 16|        
 2024-2025 Charlotte CheckersAHL13 6 814 2|        

Highlights