Matthew Schaefer

June 2025 – After much digital ink spilled online, the Islanders selected Matthew Schaefer first overall in the 2025 draft. Alex Wyatt

June – It’s been a long time since a defenceman has been as unilaterally praised as Matthew Schaefer. An elite skater, Schaefer has proven to be an explosive, agile and fluid player in all directions allowing him to control the pace of play and jump into offensive rushes with ease. Schaefer pairs this with top-tier offensive instincts, excelling in breakouts where his continuous application of deception and speed makes him a challenge for any defender to stop. Once he lands in the offensive zone, Schaefer’s skill as a triple-threat with his shot, passing, and handling ability allow him to generate chances with outstanding regularity. His passing is particularly advanced, integrating seamlessly with his puck skills to create consistent high-danger scoring chances. Defensively, he’s aggressive and anticipates plays well, closing gaps effectively with his stick and positioning. Although some physical development may be needed, Schaefer’s natural talent, elite skill-set and high-end tools make him a clear favorite for the first overall pick. In a draft light on high-end defencemen, Schaefer’s skillset and profile give him a significant edge, even with the relatively small sample size.—David Saad

January – Schaefer’s had some rotten luck this season. First battling mononucleosis, now looking at three months out of commission after breaking his collarbone at the World Juniors, it’s been hard for Schaefer to stay on the ice. Nevertheless, when Schaefer’s been healthy, he’s made a strong case to be the first name called at the draft. Over a point-per-game in the OHL (and a goal and an assist in his abbreviated two-game WJC appearance), Schaefer has done a lot to alleviate the concerns about his offensive ceiling he entered the season with. His high-end skating, efficient puck-management, and solid defence have always stood out, but some increased creativity and confidence has been fun to watch. There’s some mystery surrounding Schaefer’s projection once he returns, but as such a young prospect, he’s still got plenty of runway to push for first-overall.  Luke Sweeney